“Where Is The Thank You To London And Paris?” Ask NATO Apologists At Trinity Propaganda Event

Trinity College Dublin hosted arms lobbyists, pro-NATO thinktank experts and the Ambassador of Ukraine at a propaganda event co-organised by the university’s Ukrainian society and its Society for International Affairs. 

Share
“Where Is The Thank You To London And Paris?” Ask NATO Apologists At Trinity Propaganda Event

Trinity College Dublin hosted arms lobbyists, pro-NATO thinktank experts and the Ambassador of Ukraine at a propaganda event co-organised by the university’s Ukrainian society and its Society for International Affairs. 

The panel, which was dubbed as a discussion on what “Ukraine’s road into the EU” means, was attended by 100 people. The panelists were pro-NATO, pro-Zelensky and pro-war industry, and also expressed sentiments critical of Irish neutrality. Larsya Gerasko, Ambassador of Ukraine to Ireland, Leena Gardemeister, Ambassador of Finland to Ireland, were joined by Dr. Ben Tonra, who is involved with Lockheed Martin and the war-industry as director of the Irish Defence and Security Association (IDSA). 

Cian Fitzgerald, who is a senior researcher in security and defence policy at the Institute of International and European Affairs (IIEA), was also on the panel. The IIEA hosted NATO Deputy General Secretary Radmila Shekerinska in August 2026, which led to the building being defaced by anti-imperialist activists. Former TD Cathal Berry also spoke. He is a voice against Irish neutrality, having reprimanded former President Michael D Higgins in June 2023 over his pro-neutrality stance. The moderator of the debate was Pavlo Bogachenko, co-founder of the Ukrainian Irish Chamber of Commerce. 

Ambassador Gerasko opened the panel by stating that Ukraine is defending Europe from the Russian threat. She stated that Ukraine is winning, and making technological developments. At the same time, she condemned the Russians for targeting energy infrastructure. She talked of the need for continued funding to the Ukrainian war effort by European partners. 

Ambassador Gardemeister began by gloating about the fact that Finland, a neutral country at the time, managed to give military aid to Ukraine. “We found a way to do it, “ she said. She celebrated that Finland is no longer neutral, and celebrated its joining to the imperialist NATO. She then promulgated the myth that Finland, in 1939, was overtaken by Soviet invaders, comparing it to the 2022 invasion of Ukraine by Russia. The historical fact that these are completely unrelated, and different, contexts, clearly evaded her understanding. 

Warmongerer Cathal Berry stated that he sees Ireland as a “demilitarised zone”. He criticised the “moderates” in government. He essentially stated that Ireland is reliant on imperialist powers for its defences, citing the lack of airspace defences, the inability to track drones which became apparent last time Zelensky visited, and foreign frigates defending Dublin during the EU Presidency. “Where is the thank you to Paris and London? “, he stated. He proceeded to  speak of the bomb in Monaghan and parts for a bomb in Louth as examples of the failure of "the moderates" to say "thank you" to the big states. He claimed that this has created a growing generation of sympathisers to “obtaining political goals by violent means”. He claimed that while one person is responsible for the invasion of Ukraine, Vladimir Putin, Ireland needs to face its own “responsibility”. According to him, Putin looked at us, saw that we were “weak”, and this somehow contributed to his belief that he could attack Ukraine without pushback. 

Dr Ben Tonra echoed the words of Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney on Europe’s weakness. He stated that the European Union is a “peace project” - tell that to the Palestinians - and slammed the people as being naive about the Russian threat. He said that Putin is fielding candidates in the second round of the upcoming French presidential elections, in reference to Le Pen and Melenchon, also equating the far-left and the far-right. He also stated that he expects to see such candidates in other nations. 

Cian Fitzgerald of the IIEA said Russian hybrid warfare targets "you, me, our families", spoke of the salami technique which makes all attacks look non-serious individually, and reaction would seem disproportionate. He started listing alleged Russian attacks. One of these was “anti-semitic graffiti” across Europe to “divide the population”. He suggested to the audience as advice to “be vigilant” and “call your MEPs and TDs”.

It was at this point that the Q/A session started. One of our Aontacht Media journalists put up their hands to ask a question critical of the Zelensky government. The moderator of the panel, Pavlo Bogachenko, stated that the questions must be submitted via the Google Forms, which would undoubtedly be filtered by the organisers. 

The Q/A Google Forms is visible on the projector in the bottom-right corner.

“I would like to pose my question to the Ambassador of Ukraine directly “, dissented László Molnárfi. 

“Ambassador Gerasko, and I would like to pose this question to everyone here, why is no one addressing the elephant in the room? Ukraine is committing grave human rights abuses “, he continued. 

“We have seen forced conscription in Ukraine, men being thrown into unmarked cars, sent to be slaughtered in war. People Before Profit, Paul Murphy TD, raised this in the Dáil, condemned bussification. It's called bussification“, he stated over increasing attempts to drown him out. 

“And the FFG government here is turning back Ukrainian refugees on the orders of Zelensky and the European Union. And in Ukraine, the borders are closed and men who want to escape the war can't do so. They can't do so. And those who protest against it are put on the Myrotvorets database of state traitors, “ he continued, attempting to make his voice heard over the shouts of the crowd.

“Shame on the Zelensky regime! Shame, shame on all of you! And Dr. Ben Tonra there, he is an arms lobbyist who works with Lockheed Martin! “, he stated, as the crowd began chanting “out, out, out!”, and called security. 

0:00
/1:23

Molnárfi posing his question to Ambassador Gerasko and the attendees of the event, despite attempts to shout over him and drown out his voice.

Molnárfi was escorted away by security, as Cathal Berry compared him and others like him to “Putin’s men in Ireland”, later stating that “he’s just like Putin and his friends in Europe”. In the hallway outside, he said to Molnárfi that “you are off your meds” and that “you have blood on your hands”. 

Meanwhile, inside the room, an activist with the Communist Party of Ireland, Harun Šiljak, drew attention to Dr. Ben Tonra’s links with the war-industry. Ironically, this was not received as a shock by the audience, despite the attempt to expose his warmongering. Tonra gleefully described his work, and asserted that much insight can be gained from the war-industry for European matters. 

0:00
/1:10

Communist Party of Ireland, Harun Šiljak, drew attention to Dr. Ben Tonra’s links with the war-industry.

Later on, Olesia Zhitkova spoke of her PhD research - disinformation studies at DCU -  which is centred around the claim that all references to corruption in Ukraine are Russian propaganda, not only by Russia, but also by its supposed proxies in Ireland and EU. Olesia also noted that the “EU’s biggest strength is its biggest weakness”, that because the EU is so dedicated to free speech, it cannot stop Russian propaganda and sanction it properly. This can be understood as support for sanctions such as the one which were recently handed down by Brussels to Irish journalist Chay Bowes.

Claudia Bădulescu made a reference to Molnárfi in answering a question about EU enlargement. The question was whether Eastern European countries would feel threatened by Ukraine's agricultural production entering the EU market, and she said that "threat of conscription, as witnessed earlier, is strong, and that Poles would rather see Ukrainian wheat threaten their economy than conscription in Poland".

Ireland has already taken side in the war: Zelensky’s side against the Ukrainian people. “Neutral” Ireland is enforcing conscription against Ukrainians as part of its refugee policies. As Paul Murphy’s parliamentary request revealed, 173 Ukrainians were refused protection in Ireland since 5 August 2026. Gerasko et al seem to be happy with their compatriots being turned back, as their lives as “Professional Ukrainians” are settled with careers linked to the war’s continuation.

Members of the TCD Ukrainian Society, growing up in emigration and receiving free taxpayer-funded education at the most prestigious university in Ireland via the BOTP tuition fee scheme, seem to be unable to critically reflect on the different material realities that EU external rule subjects their working-class compatriots to - being hunted in the streets like wild animals and dragged into unmarked vehicles.

Ukrainian middle classers in Ireland left the working class and its problems back in the country with no elections, closed borders, permanent busification and Azov torture chambers. Unfortunately, they seem to have no compassion for the working class of their own country, shouting down the very possibility of questions about human rights violations in Ukraine. By doing this they condemn the working class to be slaughtered in the West’s proxy war until the last Ukrainian.

Despite their inability to put themselves in the place of their busified compatriots, they should remember: the fact that they will themselves reach conscription age someday. And considering that FFG excludes years spent on Temporary Protection from the time recognised for naturalisation purposes, and that Zelensky is openly asking EU governments to send refugees back, their own future may indeed be unpleasant. 

The war scenario they promote will inevitably lead to open EU-Russia confrontation if escalation continues.

We advise them to critically reflect on the future of social welfare supports to non-citizens and the BOTP tuition scheme in the case of this scenario, and on the future of people living in the EU on the basis of precarious Temporary Protection, who will be considered by the EU warmongers as the first candidates to be sent into the meat grinder prior to their own citizens.

0:00
/0:49