> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://aontachtmedia.ie/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Visiting The Affinity Housing Co-Op: This Is How We Solve The Housing Crisis
- URL: https://aontachtmedia.ie/visiting-the-affinity-housing-co-op-this-is-how-we-solve-the-housing-crisis/
- Published: 2026-11-22T22:07:23.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-22T22:07:23.000Z
- Description: ‘The housing crisis’, or more precisely ‘the commodification of housing crisis’ is the defining domestic issue of our generation. Alongside ‘climate collapse’, ‘state repression’, and the ‘cost of living crisis’ caused by the profiteering of large energy companies, data centres and supermarkets.
- Author: Lenses Browne
- Tags: Analysis

*‘The housing crisis’, or more precisely ‘the commodification of housing crisis’ is the defining domestic issue of our generation. Alongside ‘climate collapse’, increased ‘state repression’, and the ‘cost of living crisis’ caused by the profiteering of large energy companies, data centres and supermarket chains.*

Housing is where the extractive practices of the state and owning class are felt and seen most clearly. It is hard to ignore the obvious deprivation on the streets of Dublin or the stultification of the youth stuck in parents homes well into their thirties, or worse kept running on the treadmill of deskilled low paying work to afford the rent of a room in an overcrowded houseshare. I hardly need to explain this to the reader. They already know this, indeed they are already numb to this.

Creating robust structures to provide accommodation and community space may be a necessary prerequisite for the masses to engage with sustained political struggle. So many are currently stuck on the wage/rent treadmill and do not have the time or space to be able to develop their authentic talents or choose the direction of their labour in the world. Many others are stuck in material deprivation so deep their nervous systems can not bear to address the mechanisms of their marginalization.

Another month goes by and another record is reached in the number of recorded homeless. The figure sits at over 18,000 (1) currently and climbing. 5,900 of these are children under 18\. The long tail of this deprivation forced onto the next generation is hard to fathom. For every child recorded homeless, how many are stuck in situations of violent domestic abuse because the housing crisis enforces outsized dependency on an abuser?

Yet in the face of this crisis the government presents a face of impotent embarrassment. As if it is an issue so complex that mere mortals could barely comprehend the financial wizardry required to fix the issue. As if it is simply beyond the powers of the state or indeed society as a whole to muster the resources to meet the most basic needs of people living in the country. This is of course self-serving nonsense, that only serves to mystify how the state spends public money, as can be evidenced by a recent study from Maynooth university (2). 

With the capital invested in data centres between 2019 and 2024 the state could have built 50,000 homes. That is enough to cover everyone on the homeless register twice over and still have enough resources left over to fund the supports and integration efforts necessary to reconnect people back to wider society after living in deprivation for so long. We are living under an administration of profound irresponsibility.

To have spent that public money on water guzzling, land polluting, electricity burning, Palestinian killing, CSAM generating data centres, that produce minimal and exploitative employment; instead of building houses is the equivalent of a child spending a families rent money on fortnite skins, and then betting what is left over on the outcome of their next game.

And yet this Government would make a show of cruelty towards asylum seekers and those on social welfare to signal some kind of Thatcheresque ‘fiscal responsibility’. It is hard not to feel anything other than rage at these gaslighting shysters. Now strictly it is a mistake to accept the government's framing of housing as an issue of production rather than of distribution.

It is somewhat contentious to find up to date statistics on vacancy. Even the most recent deflated numbers show that there are at least 70,000 vacant homes in the state, this is a number based on low or no long term electricity use in the property and therefore represents the minimum. The much larger figure from the 2022 census shows the properties vacant whilst conducting the census stood at over 160,000\. This is inclusive of 49,789 unoccupied holiday homes in the state (3).

Whatever is the case in reality, it is clear that the state as currently configured is prepared to enforce the rights of the rich to their pleasure properties at the expense of those left to weather the cold of another Irish winter on the street. Again the resources are there to deal with this problem. But the state and bourgeois society have chosen to be blind and impotent.

If there is a solution to the housing crisis it will not be from state intervention. The parties in seemingly permanent power have proven that they are unwilling to entertain any solution that does not end up being just another way to funnel large swathes of public money into private hands. One in five TD’s are registered landlords (4). Why would they meaningfully intervene in a status quo, if that meant dispossessing their colleagues of such lucrative revenue streams? Why would they risk such a comfortable salary to address an issue that they themselves are insulated against? Even in the case of our quite meek social democrats or badly positioned PBP Trots, it is clear that they can not be relied on to deal with this, no one is coming to save us.

It is up to us to save ourselves. Barring some sort of imminent socialist revolution (fair play is so), any solution is going to involve the socialization of land, that is using available organizational/ legal frameworks, to take land and property off of the market and put it to a horizontal ownership structure where the relationship of tenant to landlord is abolished, It is not that this is the sum of all necessary or desirable political action. However everything that happens has to happen somewhere.

Near a small town out west is a plot of land. Out front -and under the provision of some archaic piece of legislation- it has a sign with the name of the society that owns the land. It is a very ornate sign. It reads “Affinity Collective” (4). Visiting meant so many cups of tea, amid discussions of personal, communal and political concern.

The effort that would birth the Affinity Collective housing cooperative started in 2018, a group of people experiencing extremely precarious housing came together to collectively find a way to buy land and structure its ownership so that it would be owned collectively and equally regardless of whatever money each member put into it.

Before I continue to narrate a story for how this can be done, I must speed through two very brief pieces of historical context that are necessary to trace the historical transformations of land ownership in Ireland, to where we now find ourselves. The first is enclosure starting in 1649, the second is the rent to buy scheme in the 1990s into the crash of 2008.

**Enclosure**

The historical parallels between Cromwells genocide in Ireland and the current genocide of Palestinians by the US empire is hard to miss. Having already violently occupied large swathes of land in Ireland. In October of 1641 the Connacht rebellion broke out which killed about 10,000 settlers (5). As empire seems eternally apt to do, this prompted a sort of genocide in ‘self defence’ in 1649 Oliver Cromwell and his army landed in Ireland in search of conquest and revenge. By 1658 Ireland had suffered 618,000 casualties as a direct result of the massacre, murdering an estimated 41% of the native population (6). 

This butchery laid the groundwork for the rise of landlordism in Ireland. Lands were confiscated from the native population and given as compensation to the soldiers who had carried out the massacre. Ireland was meticulously mapped and categorised by the occupying forces as to more efficiently carve it up into estates for the English gentry. Many of the natives were pushed out west into land with poorer agricultural soil. 

This was a dramatic transfer of land that would see the Anglo-Irish planting class, around 0.2% of the population come to own more than 95% of Irish land. This represents a more profound transformation than simply the transfer of land from one set of peoples to another. It fundamentally changed the logic that dictated how the land was used. 

Putting the land to colonial productivist use in service of the empire, meant that Ireland now became the beef producing ranch for England. People on the land were replaced by cows. All of the common indigenous land use practices were destroyed in favour of better serving as an economic asset to the new owners. 

Our cultural notion and naturalization to the idea of a landlord is so shaped by this. Not 

only were the people devastated but so was their knowledge of how to live with the land and places. The commons were destroyed, and with them the land suffered an ecological devastation from which it has never recovered. The whole economy was made to serve to produce for export to the empire. The brutal process of genocide to free up the land for extraction by market forces would be naturalized in the minds of subsequent generations of colonizers. 

The native population was treated with a patronizing disdain for their deprivation. This colonial genocide laid the ground work for the next one in the famine, which would see huge agricultural export from the Island at a time when millions were perishing in work houses or sucking on hail stones for nourishment building roads to nowhere to “earn their keep”. A famine created by the colonial market controlling land use.

**Rent To Buy Scheme Into The Crash** 

The Rent to Buy scheme was a government policy in the 1990s for the government to be able to sell off its social housing stock at a discount to tenants. This comes in the context of the 1970s which saw renters unions grow exponentially in response to countering capital controlled government policy broadly; and the then developing exploitation of the rental market by foreign direct investment, more specifically. 

The after effects of the 1973 renters strike are still being felt (7). In England Thatcher's government had instituted the ‘right to buy’ scheme in the 1980s, and had gone on to crush the miners strikes. This colonial measure was copied and replicated in Ireland, and was wildly successful (if people using the scheme is a measure of success); because the market dynamics it unleashed on the housing stock were self reinforcing. 

High wage earners would buy their council houses, removing them from the housing stock. As a consequence the money being brought in by local authorities became squeezed. Rent was brought up and property maintenance neglected for existing tenants, which further pushed those who could, to buy (8). 

Like most cost saving neo colonial initiatives it was extraordinarily expensive. Not having adequate housing stock meant that local authorities were forced to buy properties back from the market. This in effect meant that they could now be paying for the same houses twice. The process of opening the housing stock to the market meant that speculators could “buy low and sell high” with the local authorities footing the difference. Funnelling state capital into private hands. 

This was another very negative feedback loop that depleted both the housing stock and local authorities ability to maintain the existing housing stock. It as a measure was however quite effective in fragmenting the existing renters unions and direct action assemblages that had brought about the 1970s rent strikes. If we take it that the purpose of a thing is what it does then this was an effective suppression of the decades of work that it took to build those unions and assemblages. CATU would later emerge post the 2008 crash. Responding to the societal trauma recorded in CMATs euro country “I was twelve when da’s started killing themselves all around me”.

The choice of bail out austerity radically restructured the rental market. The percentage of home owners dropped from around 88% to 66% in 2022, entrenching intergenerational deprivation for those already economically disadvantaged.

I’m hand waving a lot of the history here, but it is important to give some context to those not familiar with how we got to this point of intense land commodification and rent extraction in Ireland. That this development goes hand in hand with ecological devastation and social atomization. That the implementation of colonial policy in the island did not end with the formation of the free state. That the opening of land to the market as facilitated by English occupation, is a situation sustained to the current day by the violence of the Guards and private security in enacting evictions.

“More effective” market manipulation and “incentivizing foreign capital” haven’t worked to alleviate the harms of the housing crisis because fundamentally they are what is causing it. When one person's home is another's speculative asset there is no way to make that relationship sustainable, because the success of one frame of land use is the failure of the other.

**The Affinity Collective Structure** 

In 2020 the collective registered as an Industrial and Provident Society with the registrar of friendly societies. This was an archaic piece of legislation that provided scope for the common ownership of land. Drafting their own constitution, it was possible to specify that decisions on the land project were to be made by consensus. 

Consensus is a system of decision making where a decision can not be made if any members of a group block it. This encourages discourse between people on decisions and generally can lead to decisions that take into account the concerns of all involved. Whilst not all socialists would agree that consensus is the most desirable decision making structure in every situation. For the purposes of a housing cooperative it makes a lot of sense and avoids reproducing the relationship of landlord and tenant under a different name.

In 2021 after getting in contact with local estate agents 8 acres of land were found for about 60,000 euro in Leitrim. The cooperative has been going for 5 years. The organizational structure which stewards the land is a sociocratic structure (11). Big decisions that concern the whole collective are brought to regular general meetings. More specific day to day tasks are usually handled either by informal communication or by meetings in specific circles. A circle -in this structure- is a working group commissioned by the collective to do some task. Not everyone needs to know everything. These groups have relative autonomy to carry out their functions. They are functions such as maintaining vehicles, building and maintaining temporary structures, ecology, events and hosting and cultural circles such as feminism.

A new member can be nominated and if there is consensus they are made a probationary member. Under the legislation a new member buys in for 1 euro.

Everyone can only own 1 euro of shares. This situation of underlying horizontal legal rights in relation to the body that owns the land means that it can only be hypothetically sold if all of the members agreed in consensus to sell the land, an event that is highly improbable unless under extreme duress. Through this the land is safe guarded against coming back on the commercial market. 

Changes in land use are rather handled by conscious discussion among members. It is this discursive mechanism that allows the relative autonomy between members to make the space together. Without fear that it will be turned into airbnb’s in a few years.

To really understand what affects this autonomy can have on creating a beautiful shared space: one ought to arrange a visit.

**Visiting The Affinity Collective**

Near a small town out west is a plot of land. Out front -and under the provision of some archaic piece of legislation- it has a sign with the name of the society that owns the land. It is a very ornate sign. It reads “Affinity Collective”. Visiting meant so many cups of tea, amid discussions of personal, communal and political concern. People ebb and flow through the communal spaces. I slept on the couch in the communal space. Jobs rotate on the peg board. Lives are lived through this shared space. Beside the couch where I slept in the communal space was a wood-stove, across a small bowel and qr code for donations.

When I asked about it, it was explained to me the economy of scale in maintaining the space. The cost of one or two extra people eating out of the pot or using the fairly minimal infrastructure was negligible. With many people coming and going; putting cash in when they have it, the fairly minimal upkeep costs are easily taken care of. They have to keep books for government oversight of the friendly society, and have an official seal on hand.

The compost toilet has some pretty good graffiti. I left a little there myself. The compost and sawdust mix is stored for -I think- two years before it becomes usable. The allotment of plants is quite impressive. There is a sort of circularity to the space. A kind of permaculture as people move freely throughout the communal spaces and personal accommodation. 

There is a general emphasis on communication and good practices in making space for people affected by a decision to have input on it. There were occasional but ongoing discussions surrounding good practices for doing so. 

When I asked about this, it was explained to me that these good practices were part of a consensus tradition where things like accessibility, equability and advocacy were -ideally- cultivated through different practices of reflection.

I went for a walk while the members had a general assembly. So much of the space is left to grow wild. Pine martins, small lizards and birds share the space and can be seen going about their business. 

As the winter months roll in, it is cold and wet when traversing up the land. This far west sees ferocious storms that have torn off roves before. We thaw in front of stoves with more cups of tea. Winter is a different part of the cycle. We chat and have meetings. I ask a question. Have you ever had to kick someone out of the collective? There is a sigh and then it is answered “yes”. It was explained to me the policy for gross misconduct. That in the case of consensus deadlock on this, there is provision in the constitution that a supermajority can vote to have someone leave. I felt it was an important question to have answered.

Exactly how do we handle eviction in our own communities? It seems that there is the necessity for this mechanism but in most cases a restorative justice approach is taken. It is explained to me that a restorative justice procedure can take a long time and a lot of conscious facilitative labour. It seemed the collective was mindful about its own culture. Possibly under the mindset that prevention was better than the cure in matters of interpersonal communication.

The cold weather marked a focus on the feminism circle. Doing the conscious work of addressing cultural assumptions taken from colonial or patriarchal models in the world. Different people engaged with these workshops at the level that was comfortable for them. Of course folks are going to have different levels of buy in and motivation.

**A Network of Communes/Rebuilding The Commons**

In returning from my visits I wondered about what the relationship was between this very particular practice and place; and a broader movement to dissolve both profit seeking in accommodation and the landlord/tenant relation. Any particular example of a horizontal housing cooperative is necessarily going to be particular to the people and space involved, because it is not about the imposition of a top down model.

To be romantic about it, one might say communes maybe bud and sprout, they don’t franchise. There's a lot that can be done with the legal/ organizational framework that has been developed in Affinity. As well as the knowledge generated by their dialectical practice of stewarding this space. 

There are as many possible permutations of socialized land put to collective use, as there are needs and desires of groups within a community. Socializing land separates it from practices of profit seeking, and makes a space more legally secure for use by the community for pro social ends.

A network of communes or socialized land projects could further secure the space. Cross membership in the legal structures could safeguard a network of cooperatives against being sold. As this issue is devolved to a wider and wider network of groups and people who mutually agree to be bound by this, then -at least on paper- it would be near impossible to sell it. Of course part of this safeguarding is developing a culture of understanding that this land is socialized, and defending that where necessary.

There are many ways in which communes can support each other. Skill sets like paperwork compliance and DIY can be shared between land projects. Now the affinity model is not the only game in town as regards cooperatives.

Of interest to those in flats suffering under the recent rent hikes. In Berlin there has been a movement to transfer whole apartment blocks to ownership by local cooperatives (12). It was possible because there was a push put on local representatives to socialize the property. Now it is in horizontal ownership without profit being extracted in the rent price. It is very possible to work towards a world without landlords and with more autonomous communal spaces. 

In Dublin there is a group of students and ex-students organizing around getting up and running student housing cooperatives. Because the price of land is so expensive in the city and around university towns. Their model is to lease a property off a local authority and structure payment of the lease so that rent does not include any profit, and is therefore below the exorbitant market rate charged by for profit student accommodations.

They seem like quite reliable young people trying to get this off the ground. With the skill sets available to them they are responding to the material circumstances they have experienced. Trying to put together a solution they will almost certainly never get to experience.

They have a lot of cash flow projections and surveys prepared. Which I suppose is necessary if you're trying to get a for cost lease from a local authority. This group has not yet managed to get a cooperative going yet. It will be interesting to see if the city council or other relevant body would be willing to allow them to put one of their many vacant properties to a much needed use. 

Social issues such as loneliness, living beyond ecological boundaries and a lack of stability can be best addressed by the development of more housing cooperatives in networks with one another. 

This may be a useful demand for the renters union as it struggles to defend its members from rent hikes, abuse and illegal eviction. To get involved with this movement first look for local groups in your area organizing towards land and communal living projects.

**To arrange a visit, get advice on setting up a cooperative or to donate land to be socialized please contact Affinity Collective at: affinitycollective@protonmail.com or find them on Instagram.** 

**To get involved with Dublin Student Housing Cooperative please contact them on their** [**Instagram**](https://www.instagram.com/dublin%5Fstudent%5Fhousing%5Fcoop/?ref=aontachtmedia.ie)**.**