> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://aontachtmedia.ie/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Union Members Are Turning On The Leaders Selling Them A Bad Deal
- URL: https://aontachtmedia.ie/union-members-are-turning-on-the-leaders-selling-them-a-bad-deal/
- Published: 2026-11-20T23:10:30.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-20T23:10:30.000Z
- Description: Union officials across the public sector have been working overtime to sell the agreement to their members, with some reportedly describing it as the best deal they could secure. The backlash has been furious.
- Author: Alex Homits
- Tags: Analysis

# **Social Partnership: The Cracks Are Beginning to Show**

For the first time since 1987, social partnership (or ‘social dialogue’, as it is now being rebranded) is facing a serious challenge.

For readers unfamiliar with the concept, social partnership is the idea that trade unions, employers and the Government (itself an employer, but we’ll leave that aside for now) are stakeholders who can come together, through discussion and negotiation, to reach agreements in the interests of the country and its workers. The primary benefit for the Government and certain employers is industrial peace, secured through mechanisms such as the no-strike clauses contained in the current public service agreement. For workers, the supposed benefits are steady, guaranteed pay increases and a ‘seat at the table’.

The recent negotiations and proposed draft agreement have generated considerable debate, discussion and, ironically, dialogue. Much of this controversy stems from the apparent suppression of those very things within the public sector unions themselves. This week, information sessions featuring pre-screened questions were organised. Despite most public sector unions having well-resourced, member-funded offices throughout the country, there have been no corresponding efforts to organise meaningful in-person membership meetings.

Union officials across the public sector have been working overtime to sell the agreement to their members, with some reportedly describing it as the best deal they could secure. The backlash has been furious. Members of SIPTU, INTO, TUI, Fórsa and ASTI have been organising across union boundaries in support of a ‘No’ vote. Along the way, they have reported tactics more reminiscent of modern HR practices in the private sector than the traditions of trade unionism.

In an apparent effort to avoid responsibility for recommending a deal widely regarded as inadequate, some officials have reportedly shifted the blame onto other unions, suggesting that they were unwilling to take strike action. This raises an important question: which union, if any, overrode the mandate of its own members and communicated that position to the other unions on the negotiating team?

Another major source of anger has been the unilateral suspension of industrial action, including work-to-rule measures, without consulting members. Furious teachers and civil servants have challenged their unions publicly, perhaps for the first time, questioning why such decisions were made when no agreement had yet been reached. Others have criticised the decision to suspend national demonstrations on a pivotal and strategically important day, describing it as ‘stealing defeat from the jaws of victory’.

Unions mobilised their members, marched them up the hill and beat their drums, only to suspend industrial action in pursuit of an agreement that restricts their members' ability to strike on matters covered by its terms. What is being offered in return? A below-inflation pay deal, no meaningful resolution to the Croke Park hours, the SNA 72 hours issue, and a myriad of other problems that the unions themselves have built campaigns around. Fórsa's ‘Campaign for a Better Deal’ immediately springs to mind. It was an ambitious campaign that compelled members of Fórsa to commit to not accept a new deal that didn’t include some of the life changing and structural reforms the union sought. Now the same leadership is asking its members to break that commitment a year later for a deal that doesn’t include anything they had set up a campaign for in 2025!

Likewise in SIPTU, all of the fighting talk, James Connolly quotes and pictures with Mick Lynch have resulted in a recommendation for a deal with a no strike clause and below inflation pay increases. Perhaps this was inevitable in SIPTU as the General Secretary is a man who has never worked a real job and is an unapologetic member of a Party that cut lone parents allowance and tried to criminalise working class people resisting water charges.

The result has been thousands of legitimately angry members and a vocal, growing ‘Vote No’ campaign spreading throughout the unions. The belligerent attitude of some officials, coupled with what members perceive as half-truths and contradictory explanations, has left many questioning what is really going on.

Why energise the trade union movement, encourage members to mobilise and build industrial pressure, only to then attempt to push through what is, at best, an average agreement?

What many trade union members across the country may not realise is that this cosy relationship between union leadership, government and employers is not a new phenomenon. It has been an intrinsic feature of social partnership for decades.

Consider the austerity years. The Irish Congress of Trade Unions, and SIPTU in particular, were heavily constrained by their relationship with a coalition partner, the Labour Party, and offered virtually no meaningful opposition to the savage austerity measures imposed on workers. A one-day strike in opposition to the bank bailout was seemingly the limit of their ambitions. The outcome was an agreement that slashed workers' pay and conditions and sacrificed the interests of the next generation of public sector workers.

Social partnership also helped create comfortable retirement pathways for a wide range of former union officials, who moved into positions as adjudicators, Labour Court panellists, consultants and members of various boards and committees. There is a very real revolving door in this country, and it is not particularly difficult to follow.

But the problem goes beyond the continuation of individual career trajectories into state institutions and government-linked positions. It is also about the material circumstances and lifestyles of many senior union officials. The salaries and allowances they receive, the culture of comfortable relations with the State and the standards of living they enjoy have created an enormous gulf between the upper echelons of the trade union movement and ordinary members.

For perhaps the first time in a long time, workers and trade unionists are beginning to recognise that divide in a very tangible way: through an agreement that is simply not good enough, yet is being actively promoted by their own officials.

As trade unionists find their feet and become more active participants in their organisations, there is a very real possibility that, for the first time, an agreement born out of the social partnership model will receive a significant minority ‘No’ vote across the unions representing public sector workers.

The agreement will more than likely still pass. However, something important may already have changed. A new generation of trade unionists, forged in the fires of an industrial dispute and a bitter sense of betrayal by their own union leadership, may lay the foundations for a more transparent, democratic and member-led trade union movement. One that operates more inclusively, particularly when it comes to negotiations, the suspension of industrial action and decisions that fundamentally affect members' working lives.

If the agreement fails, union leadership bodies will have a clear mandate to regroup, reorganise and, crucially, re-engage their own members. They will have an opportunity to return to negotiations with a renewed mandate and pursue the structural and long-term concessions necessary to materially improve the lives of working people.

Ultimately, workers hold the power. The anger generated by imperialism, social decay and deepening inequality cannot simply be dissipated through another round of managed negotiations and carefully choreographed social dialogue. It must be harnessed and channelled into meaningful long term, structural change in Irish society.

The question is no longer simply whether workers will vote for or against this agreement. It is whether they are prepared to reclaim their trade unions as democratic organisations that answer to their members, rather than expecting members to answer to them.