> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://aontachtmedia.ie/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# "A Change Of Drivers Is No Good": The Vision Of The Saor Éire Platform
- URL: https://aontachtmedia.ie/a-change-of-drivers-is-no-good-the-vision-of-the-saor-eire-platform/
- Published: 2026-11-21T21:34:38.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-21T21:34:38.000Z
- Description: The Saor Éire political platform emerged in 1931 from within the Irish Republican Army (IRA) and argued that national independence was meaningless without social and economic change.
- Author: Tadgh Ó Cuill-Maonlaí
- Tags: Analysis

The Saor Éire political platform emerged in 1931 from within the Irish Republican Army (IRA) and argued that national independence was meaningless without social and economic change. Its founders sought to combine opposition to British rule with a programme that recognised the broad scope of imperialism in Ireland. They directed their efforts against domestic capitalism, landlordism and poverty. Although relatively short-lived, Saor Éire’s draft constitution is revealing, as it proposed an independent Ireland governed by workers and working farmers, and reimagined republicanism through class politics. Such an initiative was to be led by the IRA.

The organisation grew from debates about republicanism after the Civil War. By the late 1920s, the IRA’s guerrilla campaign had failed to restore the Republic proclaimed in 1916 and affirmed in 1919, and some activists argued that it needed to do more to actively engage with the everyday conditions of ordinary people. Army Executive member Peadar O’Donnell was a prominent advocate of this turn, while GHQ’s David Fitzgerald was central to the socialist economic analysis in Saor Éire’s programme. George Gilmore and Frank Ryan, who also served stints on the Army Executive, were prominently associated with this republican current. A proposal was put to an IRA Army Congress in 1929, and a revised programme was endorsed in 1931\. Saor Éire’s first national congress took place in Dublin during September 1931, adopting its constitution and rules (Hanley, 2002; Casey, 2022). In recognition of the fallout caused by the onset of the Great Depression, Saor Éire was ultimately the initiative of the IRA’s Army Council, noting that such an entity was a recognition of the need to form “a Civil Revolutionary organisation to support the Army and carry the teaching of its principles down through the people, from whom the Volunteer movement had become rather isolated.” Moss Twomey, as the-then chief-of-staff, supported the initiative. Seán MacBride (son of John MacBride and Maud Gonne MacBride), who would later serve as the IRA’s chief-of-staff, was another important figure in Saor Éire's establishment in 1931\. Sean MacBride’s entry in the ‘*Dictionary of Irish Biography*’ notes that Saor Éire was (albeit briefly) effectively the political wing of those on the anti-treaty side who were opposed to de Valera's espousal of constitutional politics within the treaty state’s framework. MacBride would even say at one point that he was prepared to “go the whole hog for the Workers’ Republic” (Hanley, 2001; Keane, 2009). A Department of Justice brief referred to Saor Éire as “frankly communistic” and that “the chief organisers were all… prominent members of the IRA” (Hammill, 1995).

The political and economic context mattered. Saor Éire’s opening declaration described unemployment, insecure work, indebted farmers and small traders squeezed by powerful financial and commercial interests. It argued that the Free State had preserved the structures of wealth and power associated with landlords and banks. In its view, the superficial, colonial transfer of political office from London to Dublin had not dismantled the system that impoverished workers and small farmers. A mere change of government was inadequate, noting that “a change of drivers is no good” if the machinery itself remained unchanged (Saor Éire, 1931, p. 3). This challenged both the legitimacy of the Free State and republican politics that treated national sovereignty as only the establishment of a different jurisdiction.

As an article in ‘Armed Forces & Society’ highlights, Saor Éire was established “with the intention of being recognised as a leftist party campaigning for agrarian reform” (Page and Smith, 2000). The constitution, headed ‘An Organisation of Workers and Working Farmers,’ translated this argument into a detailed programme. Its objectives included breaking the connection with England, securing Irish national sovereignty and vesting political power in the working class and working farmers. It went beyond softer and more constitutionalist nationalist demands, proposing the abolition, without compensation, of landlordism in land, fisheries and minerals; the development of essential industries through workers’ co-operatives under state direction, and agricultural development through state credit and farmers’ co-operatives. Banking and credit, imports and exports, and public inland transport were to become state monopolies or state-controlled services (Saor Éire, 1931, pp. 5–6).

An article from ‘An Phoblacht’ on 3 October 1931, titled ‘The Clarion Call of Saor Éire: Why Ireland’s Workers and Working Farmers Must Organise to Undo the Conquest,’ condemned the Irish Free State and the Treaty for betraying the ideals of the 1916 Republic and failing to address social and economic inequality. Referring to a variety of statistics, the piece argued that a capitalist system, combined with British economic warfare and domestic policies like the Land Act of 1923, heavily favoured large landowners while devastating small farmers and agricultural workers. Backed by stark statistics on falling agricultural prices, shrinking farm holdings, and mass emigration, the article asserted that the rural working class was being crushed by debt and poverty. Ultimately, it declared the Irish Republic the only legitimate government and called for a unified front of workers and farmers to overthrow the Free State and undo the conquest (An Phoblacht, 1931).

The social programme was equally ambitious. Housing was to become a state responsibility; every citizen was to be guaranteed a minimum standard of living, whether employed or not; and social insurance was to support older people, widows, orphans and those unable to work through physical or mental incapacity. The constitution also called for the end of imperial tribute, the restoration of Irish language and culture, and closer co-operation between rural and urban workers. It presented workers and farmers not as competing interests, but as allies exploited by the same economic system. National self-determination was thus linked to material security, control of national wealth, and collective economic ownership.

Saor Éire also envisaged a structure for mobilising support. It proposed committees of action among industrial and agricultural workers to organise resistance and build revolutionary leadership. The constitution provided for local branches, district committees, an annual National Convention and a National Executive. Membership was open to those over sixteen who accepted its objectives and methods. Its declared means included mobilising the population behind a revolutionary government to overthrow British imperialism and its domestic allies and establish a Workers’ State (Saor Éire, 1931, pp. 6–8). The document combined a programme for a future republic with a plan for political activity in the present.

Women were a key part of this initiative. Activists including Helena Molony and Sighle Humphreys were founding members or served on the executive, connecting Saor Éire to republican activism, trade unionism and campaigns against poverty. However, Molony, a prominent trade unionist, resigned from the founding executive within a month under pressure from the Irish Women Workers’ Union leadership (White and Clarke, 2009; Maume, 2009).

In October 1931, W.T. Cosgrave, then President of the Free State’s Executive Council and leader of Cumann na nGaedheal, denounced Saor Éire in the Free State Dáil. He claimed that “within the past few months a new element of danger has been added to our existing perils. The I.R.A. has accepted as its ally the new organisation known as ‘Saor Eire,' which is simply an organisation for setting up in this country a State on the lines of the Russian Soviet Republic.” Asserting that “many of the organisers of ‘Saor Eire’ have, in fact, actually been in Russia to receive training in the authentic Soviet gospel,” he also claimed that “the existence of such an organisation in our midst, in active co-operation with an organised band of armed criminals \[*i.e., the IRA*\], at a time when we are endeavouring to ward off from this State the terrible economic disasters of other countries is so obvious a menace that I need not emphasise it” (Houses of the Oireachtas, 1931).

Saor Éire made international headlines in December 1931, when ‘TIME Magazine’ reported on the first person to be sentenced under the new laws by a Military Tribunal, John Mulgrew. In 1923, he travelled to the United States, obtained citizenship, and returned to Ireland in 1930\. He had admitted to being a member of what ‘TIME’ called the “Communistic Saor Eire’s" executive council when he was accused of membership of a proscribed organisation. This instance involved real and serious issues involving the right to a fair trial and due process, having vowed that the confession was "twisted out of me by the third degree." Furthermore, this draconian legislation, which could impose a death penalty, possessed no right of appeal. Nevertheless, he received a sentence that included deportation after six months of hard labour (TIME, 1931).

Saor Éire’s prospects were quickly curtailed by opposition from church and state. In October 1931, the Catholic hierarchy issued a collective pastoral condemning its programme, portraying class conflict and the abolition of private property as threats to religion and social order. The Cumann na nGaedheal government also enacted the Constitution (Amendment No. 17) Act, 1931, which created exceptional public-safety powers and enabled organisations to be declared unlawful. Saor Éire was among the organisations outlawed in the crackdown (Casey, 2022; Irish Statute Book, 1931). Repression, hostile public controversy and limited support within the wider IRA undermined the project. The organisation soon collapsed, and the IRA leadership retreated from the radical programme that had briefly energised its more overt left wing (Casey, 2022). In some instances, it was believed that churchmen had collaborated with the gardaí to influence people to leave the IRA. At a Mass in the village of Annacarty, South Co. Tipperary, the priest used his sermon about the achievements of the Eucharistic Congress to assert that the clerical prohibition on Saor Éire was still applied and that it was a “mortal sin” to join the IRA. Seán MacSwiney (a Cork city councillor, brother of the martyred Terence, and a local IRA officer in Cork City) who had previously been secretary of the Irish section of Comintern’s League Against Imperialism, now said that “no Christian could be a Communist.” The sustained attack by the press and the clergy had made it more difficult to recruit young men into the organisation, with leading figure Tom Barry of west Cork noting that the Hierarchy’s claim that “no Catholic could be a Communist” had hampered the ability to grow the IRA's membership. Similarly, the Belfast IRA asserted that ‘An Phoblacht’ was “too communistic,” and asked why Saor Éire was chosen as the IRA’s political platform, rather than Sinn Fein. It’s often forgotten that the Sinn Fein party, as Prof. Brian Hanley points out, had drifted further and further away from the IRA during this period. Sinn Fein didn’t partake in the Land Annuities agitation or the IRA’s revamped anti-imperialist campaigns. It became increasingly critical of the IRA’s policies, and vice-versa. Its collapse is illustrated by the fact that only 60 people attended the party’s Ard Fheis in 1930\. Indeed, Saor Éire was perceived as the intended successor to the role Sinn Fein once played as the political wing of the IRA. Despite Saor Éire’ collapse in 1933 and the environment of the time, the IRA would still employ what was regarded as communistic rhetoric in its propaganda (Hanley, 2002).

Saor Éire’s legacy, however, isn’t measured by its lifespan. It articulated a coherent attempt by the IRA leadership to create a campaigning platform, consistent with the ideas of James Connolly, Liam Mellows, Pádraig Pearse and other visionary republicans, that fused general anti-imperialism with class struggle, and some of its activists helped prepare the ground for the Republican Congress established in 1934\. Richard English identifies a central division within republicanism. That is, whether social change should wait until the Irish Republic was won, or whether the struggle for a republic had to be socialist from the outset (English, 1990). Saor Éire was an explicit expression of the latter position. Its constitution remains valuable evidence of a vision of Irish freedom founded on political sovereignty, workers’ power and social justice.

[ANP-1931-10-03.5ANP-1931-10-03.5.pdf3 MBdownload-circle](https://aontachtmedia.ie/content/files/2026/11/ANP-1931-10-03.5.pdf "Download")

**Bibliography**

- Hammill, J. (1995) ‘Saor Éire and the IRA: An Exercise in Deception?’, Saothar: Journal of the Irish Labour History Society, 20, pp. 56–66\. Available at: [https://www.jstor.org/stable/23197224](https://www.jstor.org/stable/23197224?ref=aontachtmedia.ie)
- Casey, M.J. (2022) ‘The transnational life of David Fitzgerald (1897–1933)’, in Devine, F. and Mac Bhloscaidh, F. (eds.) Bread not Profits: Provincial Working Class Politics During the Irish Revolution. Umiskin Press, pp. 116–128\. Available at: [https://pureadmin.qub.ac.uk/ws/portalfiles/portal/434170564/The\_Transnational\_World\_of\_David\_Fitzgerald.pdf](https://pureadmin.qub.ac.uk/ws/portalfiles/portal/434170564/The%5FTransnational%5FWorld%5Fof%5FDavid%5FFitzgerald.pdf?ref=aontachtmedia.ie)
- English, R. (1990) ‘Socialism and republican schism in Ireland: the emergence of the Republican Congress in 1934’, Irish Historical Studies, 27(105), pp. 48–65\. Available at: [https://doi.org/10.1017/S0021121400010300](https://doi.org/10.1017/S0021121400010300?ref=aontachtmedia.ie)
- Irish Statute Book (1931) Constitution (Amendment No. 17) Act, 1931 (No. 37 of 1931). Available at: [https://www.irishstatutebook.ie/eli/1931/act/37/enacted/en/print.html](https://www.irishstatutebook.ie/eli/1931/act/37/enacted/en/print.html?ref=aontachtmedia.ie)
- Maume, P. (2009) ‘Humphreys, Sighle (Mary Ellen; Sighle Bean Uí Dhonnchadha)’, Dictionary of Irish Biography. Available at: [https://www.dib.ie/biography/humphreys-sighle-mary-ellen-sighle-bean-ui-dhonnchadha-a4157](https://www.dib.ie/biography/humphreys-sighle-mary-ellen-sighle-bean-ui-dhonnchadha-a4157?ref=aontachtmedia.ie)
- Saor Éire (1931) Draft Constitution and Rules. Irish Left Archive. Available at: [https://www.leftarchive.ie/document/6252/](https://www.leftarchive.ie/document/6252/?ref=aontachtmedia.ie)
- (White, L.W. and Clarke, F. (2009) ‘Molony, Helena’, Dictionary of Irish Biography. Available at: [https://www.dib.ie/biography/molony-helena-a5874](https://www.dib.ie/biography/molony-helena-a5874?ref=aontachtmedia.ie)
- TIME (1931) ‘Ireland: Rebels & Razzberries’, 14 December. Available at: [https://time.com/archive/6863295/ireland-rebels-razzberries/](https://time.com/archive/6863295/ireland-rebels-razzberries/?ref=aontachtmedia.ie)
- Houses of the Oireachtas (1931) ‘Dáil Éireann debate, Wednesday, 14 October 1931’, Dáil Éireann Debates, vol. 40, no. 1\. Available at: [https://www.oireachtas.ie/en/debates/debate/dail/1931-10-14/33/](https://www.oireachtas.ie/en/debates/debate/dail/1931-10-14/33/?ref=aontachtmedia.ie)
- Keane, R. (2009) ‘MacBride, Seán’, Dictionary of Irish Biography. Royal Irish Academy. Available at: [https://www.dib.ie/biography/macbride-sean-a5109](https://www.dib.ie/biography/macbride-sean-a5109?ref=aontachtmedia.ie)
- Hanley, B. (2002) The IRA, 1926–1936\. Dublin: Four Courts Press. Available at: <https://archive.org/details/ira192619360000hanl/mode/2up>
- Hanley, B. (2001) ‘Moss Twomey, radicalism, and the IRA, 1931–33: a reassessment’, Saothar, 26, pp. 53–60\. Available at: [https://www.jstor.org/stable/23198999](https://www.jstor.org/stable/23198999?ref=aontachtmedia.ie)
- An Phoblacht (1931) ‘The Clarion Call of Saor Eire’, 3 October, p. 5.
- Page, M. von Tangen and Smith, M.L.R. (2000) ‘War by other means: The problem of political control in Irish Republican strategy’, Armed Forces & Society, 27(1), pp. 79–104\. Available at: [https://www.jstor.org/stable/45346401](https://www.jstor.org/stable/45346401?ref=aontachtmedia.ie)